There are three types of holdings: Baronies: Focus on troops. ? Long story short, I was ruling as the king of Ireland but my character had terrible traits and was hated by everyone and was eventually excommunicated, making everyone hate me more. Fast forward a generation and the Pope went off on a crusade on the other end of the map. You aren't supposed to directly hold cities or temples as a feudal lord. One of the most common errors made by new players of Crusader Kings 2 is to spend too much time focusing on personal success and acquiring as many titles as. 700+. I got this message when I revoked the title of major of Sigtuna (a city) from an underling. Fast forward a generation and the. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. For the counties I usually go to the intrigue tab to recruit a noble/soldier/holy men. This however triggered two consequences I do not understand. I revoked a the title of mayor of a main city of a holding from a vassal. . I'm currently the Petty King of Meath. makes sense. 1 coastal holdings/county. No 6-holding. It isn't listed as one of my demesnes that I can assign to someone else. What does it mean, and how do I fix it?Two other thing of note, Demesne size is counting the number of titles you hold, not the number of counties. What does it mean, and how do I fix it?For example, my capital has 6 slots, all of them belong to different vassals and I don't even seem to have a claim on them (even though I'm the heir, if the current title holder dies and I get it, it will just say "wrong type of holding"). Do I have to give mayorship of this town to one of my vassals? If I do that or don't what are the economic consequenses? I saved for a long time to build this town so I could bring in some more cash. 9/8/2023. Unless your are above your demesne limit I wouldnt care much about it. The above-mentioned most important and obvious factors are your demesne limit (top right corner of your screen; this is the number of counties or baronies you hold personally) and the number of ducal titles you hold if you're a king or emperor (this can't be above 2 or you face opinion penalties; just click the face of your character and you'll. There are three types of holdings: Baronies: Focus on troops. Wrong Type Of Holding In Demesne Ck2 Change Holding Type; Wrong Type Of Holding In Demesne / dɪˈmeɪn, -ˈmin / noun. . Also, it can be a good idea to not grant too many holdings to one vassal. Any help would be appreciated. For example, whenever you propose peace to. 1 coastal holdings/county. 700+. Feudals aren't generally allowed to hold cities or temples without penalty. 21 total. Crusader Kings 2 Taxes, Levy and Laws Taxes There are 3 types of holdings in CK2: Castles are owned by feudal lords Churches are owned by bishops Cities are owned by mayors You are a feudal lord so having a city or a church in your demesne is considered having a wrong type of holding and you get 25% penalty to the holding's base income (BI): The Basics. 5 for a tribe, 4 for a castle, 8 for a temple, or 12. Alternatively, if that county level title is held by a mayor, I think he. I'm currently the Petty King of Meath. Either to an unlanded courtier, previously landed vassal or a newly created one through the given holding's menu. Everything I fight for goes to someone else so people have said to build your own in your own counties. I'm currently the Petty King of Meath. I revoked a the title of mayor of a main city of a holding from a vassal. . But now I see Wrong type of holding in demesne message. Still super new to this game and I'm in need of some help. Afterwards, I got the "wrong type of holding" warning, and each holding in the three provinces is labeled with a "recently conquered" modifier for wrong religion, wrong culture, etc. I am listed as the holder of the city of Newark, so I keep getting the "wrong type of holding" alert. For example, my capital has 6 slots, all of them belong to different vassals and I don't even seem to have a claim on them (even though I'm the heir, if the current title holder dies and I get it, it will just say "wrong type of holding"). All but 1 are coastal. Everything I fight for goes to someone else so people have said to build your own in your own counties. . A ruler's demesne limit is based on tier, personal and spouse stewardship, succession type, and centralization law. . Any help would be appreciated. NapoleonI. Fast forward a generation and the. as you cannot build multiple tribal holdings in one county and get crippling penalties for wrong holding type. A holding will receive pretty significant tax and levy penalties with the wrong type of ruler. Bedford has a castle and I'm still tribal. I have looked at the titles for that county (Perfeddwlad - Wales) and I have nothing for the Major of Dendigh which the title was originally. Counties can have 3 types of holdings - baronies, cities, and bishoprics. Wiki. The three holdings in question were 2 cities and a bishopric that I had recently conqured. Barons are affected by feudal ta, mayors are. Some time ago - I'm not even sure it was my current ruler - I married somebody off into Bedford. Some time ago - I'm not even sure it was my current ruler - I married somebody off into Bedford. Wrong type of holding in demesne NapoleonI Feb 21, 2012 Jump to latest Follow Reply I got this message when I revoked the title of major of Sigtuna (a city) from. And how I can change this. Still super new to this game and I'm in need of some help. To lift the excommunication I gifted the Pope a county (Connact) to raise his opinion of me. After I let a vassal have control of it. My demesne limit is only 3 and I'm not sure what to do at this point. ? Long story short, I was ruling as the king of Ireland but my character had terrible traits and was hated by everyone and was eventually excommunicated, making everyone hate me more. Hello, I would like to know more about this game since i find it difficult than other strategies, some things i have learned in hard way and some i still can not. Business, Economics, and Finance. Fast forward a generation and the. Feb 21, 2012. Do I have to give mayorship of this town to one of my vassals? If I do that or don't what are the economic consequenses? I saved for a long time to build this town so I could bring in some more cash. Some time ago - I'm not even sure it was my current ruler - I married somebody off into Bedford. 700+. The formula for each vassal is: Liege Taxes = Vassal Income x Tax Percentage x Penalty Modifiers. an estate or part of an estate occupied and controlled by, and worked for the exclusive use of, the owner. . . Still super new to this game and I'm in need of some help. 28 total. I just finished a war in which I gained my second province, the southern most one on the island of Sardinia. Each of these three types have an associated. Years later, my current king inherits the county and now I have the "Wrong type of Holding in Demesne" message. There are three types of holdings: Baronies: Focus on troops. 21 coastal. types - castles, cities, temples or tribes. So should I just spread out my demesne across the entire realm, with few castles here and there, instead of controlling everything. Wrong Type Of Holding In Demesne Ck2. Bedford has a castle and I'm still tribal. For example, my capital has 6 slots, all of them belong to different vassals and I don't even seem to have a claim on them (even though I'm the heir, if the current title holder dies and I get it, it will just say "wrong type of holding"). The first is all cities all the time, and fill out your demesne with counties for extra baron taxation income. It includes the vassal's demesne income, liege tax from their own vassals, and trade income. I just built a city in my capitol county, and it says "Holder is of wrong holding type". In a separate issue, I have towns/castles that I can't upgrade because it says I don't have Keeps II which I do have. ? Long story short, I was ruling as the king of Ireland but my character had terrible traits and was hated by everyone and was eventually excommunicated, making everyone hate me more. If I select a vassal and grant landed title, I only get a. Jun 18, 2015 at 5:20. . I. Temples & cities offer useless levy even at full strength. There's also penalties to holding too many titles. . ? Long story short, I was ruling as the king of Ireland but my character had terrible traits and was hated by everyone and was eventually excommunicated, making everyone hate me more. I revoked it for myself and became a count worchester as I believe I am supposed to be. . Fast forward a generation and the. One 6-holding. Best way to fix it is to give it away to someone who isn't already a ruler. So I was playing the demo earlier and an 'alert button' popped up saying that a few of my provinces were the wrong type of holding in my demesne. I'm currently the Petty King of Meath. . 700+. where: Vassal Income is the vassal's total steady income. Any help would be appreciated. . If you don't use Ironman for your current game, you can open the console by typing any of the following: On German/Nordic keyboards, this is ⇧Shift + 3 This may also be the combo of left shift and the §| key to the left of the number 1 on the number row. Crusader Kings III > General Discussions > Topic Details. . 7: Barcelona. No 6-holding. It's nice to be able to revoke the titles penalty-free when you need more holdings in your domain. They are not the right type of holding. Do I have to give mayorship of this town to one of my vassals? If I do that or don't what are the economic consequenses? I saved for a long time to build this town so I could bring in some more cash. Either give it to an existing courtier or create a random new one out of thin air by right clicking. . Thank you. Still super new to this game and I'm in need of some help. If you control a city and isn't a republic you should have a "wrong type of holding in demesne" alert at the top of the screen. Any help would be appreciated. So my count, which rules of two counties died. First thing you need to know is that as a feudal christain lord you can only hold castles without a big penalty, temples and towns are the wrong type of holding. Each County that makes up your personal domain is divided up into a number of Baronies. For example, my capital has 6 slots, all of them belong to different vassals and I don't even seem to have a claim on them (even though I'm the heir, if the current title holder dies and I get it, it will just say "wrong type of holding"). I now get the warning/message "Wrong type of holding in Demesne"; what does that do? It doesn't say what penalties there are. Fast forward a generation and the. I revoked it for myself and became a count worchester as I believe I am supposed to be. Everything I fight for goes to someone else so people have said to build your own in your own counties. Why is this considered "Wrong Type Of Holding In Demesne" despite being a chiefdom In my current game I started out playing a viking from the petty kingdom of Gotland. de·mesne (dĭ-mān′, -mēn′) n. Some time ago - I'm not even sure it was my current ruler - I married somebody off into Bedford. ? Long story short, I was ruling as the king of Ireland but my character had terrible traits and was hated by everyone and was eventually excommunicated, making everyone hate me more. You’d want to abandon your holdings in Brittany since you’re at risk of a holy. " By Anyone-4-CS in forum Networking & Security Replies: 6. . New player here; my son and I just bought CK2 a few days ago. makes sense. Do I have to give mayorship of this town to one of my vassals? If I do that or don't what are the economic consequenses? I saved for a long time to build this town so I could bring in some more cash. They are not the right type of holding. The best ways to do this is to either simply revoke the baron's title (which WILL give you an opinion hit from all your other vassals, but is often still the simpler of. . < 1 2 > Showing 1 - 15 of 26 comments Hurodrik Feb 17, 2016 @ 9:00am You are a feudal lord. The Basics. Do I have to give mayorship of this town to one of my vassals? If I do that or don't what are the economic consequenses? I saved for a long time to build this town so I could bring in some more cash. Counts and Barons earn income from their demesne, they pay a percentage to their Duke, who pays a percentage of their total income to their King, who pays a percentage of their total income to their Emperor. . 19 coastal. Also, if you are not at your demesne limit you can hold onto wrong holdings. If I select a vassal. Temples & cities offer useless levy even at full strength. I was playing as. You can see it has a city as county capital but it's held by a duke (noble) so it's the wrong type of holding. For the counties I usually go to the intrigue tab to recruit a noble/soldier/holy men. Rogues are the masters of stealthy combat and ranged weapons. I just built a city in my capitol county, and it says "Holder is of wrong holding type". Bishoprics: A middle ground between baronies and cities. I revoked it for myself and became a count worchester as I believe I am supposed to be. I'm currently the Petty King of Meath. . One 6-holding. I have this and I dont know how to fix it. Bedford has a castle and I'm still tribal. FAQ: Wrong Holding/Government Type. 5: Tunis. Everything I fight for goes to someone else so people have said to build your own in your own counties. Every county has at least one holding, and most have three. Feudals aren't generally allowed to hold cities or temples without penalty. Barons have baronies, mayors have cities, and bishops have bishoprics. My income in that province increased greatly. There are four systems of government feudalism, theocracy, republic and tribal. 19 coastal. Fast forward a generation and the. Years later, my current king inherits the county and now I have the "Wrong type of Holding in Demesne" message. . These holdings provide both income and taxes, and every holding is held by a character. This will only work for the subholdings, so for the main holding you're going to have to either give it away to someone else or create a tribal holding in one. What exactly does this mean?Wrong settlement type [edit | edit source] Characters get a 75% penalty to income and levies in demesne settlements that do not match their government type. As a King can only hold two Duchies without a large opinion penalty from. If you have the wrong holding type you take about 25% of the base income as income. Thank you. . You lose 75% of the. And even better, almost all of these have added some sort of hidden easter egg. The plot concluded and I won the county back, but I am now getting a message that says: Wrong type of holding in demesne. 700+. So all I can build are castles (and still own them)?? So I have to give yet another holding away? Build a city of your own and give it away. If the county level title is held by a baron, which is most commonly the case, that baron becomes a count. What is the actual penalty for holding these?I don't understand this. Do I have to give mayorship of this town to one of my vassals? If I do that or don't what are the economic consequenses? I saved for a long time to build this town so I could bring in some more cash. Ck2 Pillage Holding; Such holdings may either be counties or baronies. I hold Leicester as Earl. , I imprison/banish a mayor (as a king with one county), and take possession of his title. g. ) Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without penalty, but can easily build new tribes in conquered territory; they can also build temples. Wrong Type Of Holding In Demesne; Some of them are pretty easy to spot. I don't understand this. makes sense. It doesnt really help much though, its just a way to spend money. Barons have baronies, mayors have cities, and bishops have bishoprics. Cities: Focus on tax. . I am a new player of CK2 (current patch) playing as the feudal King of Sweden on the standard start date. Bedford has a castle and I'm still tribal. So should I just spread out my demesne across the entire realm, with few castles here and there, instead of controlling everything. So all I can build are castles (and still own them)?? So I have to give yet another holding away? Build a city of your own and give it away. I don't understand this. I have this and I dont know how to fix it. Wrong type of holding in demesne. . Ok, so it say upgrade the holding, but says I can't upgrade it because some previous putz put a castle in the lower holding. A demesne is a character's collection of personal. Nomadism is also one of three playable non-feudal government types in CK2, the other two being merchant republics and tribalism. So all I can build are castles (and still own them)?? So I have to give yet another holding away? Build a city of your own and give it away. Tax Percentage is set by liege law. . Fast forward a generation and the. Fast forward a generation and the. Hi My question is, what are the consequences (cons and maybe there are some pros) of having a a wrong holding type or a big demense? From what I know: Cons of having a big demense: - Problems with taxes? Cons of having a wrong holding type: -. They are not the right type of holding. Crusader Kings 2 Taxes, Levy and Laws Taxes There are 3 types of holdings in CK2: Castles are owned by feudal lords Churches are owned by bishops Cities are owned by mayors You are a feudal lord so having a city or a church in your demesne is considered having a wrong type of holding and you get 25% penalty to the holding's base income. They are not the right type of holding. They are not the right type of holding. In CK2 some of them do so (to compensate their land being de facto so heavily underrated), and their military power is based on mercenaries (Mamluks of Egypt, Ghilman of Iraq/Persia) That would be ok, if these armies were not supported by quite massive vasal and demesne levies. If you give it to a vasall you will get at least 45/50% or more percent of the base income. . Everything I fight for goes to someone else so people have said to build your own in your own counties. types - castles, cities, temples or tribes. As such, your first goal should be level 2 in all holdings before you upgrade any further. Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Hover over the other ruler's demesne. The three holdings in question were 2 cities and a bishopric that I had. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. I'm currently the Petty King of Meath. Fast forward a generation and the. The primary source of wealth for most rulers. If dynasty is in a weak position stockpile as much gold as possible for mercenaries and bribes. Step3: Give away the. I guess it's because the capital is temple and I should put some bishop to rule there, right?Facts and opinions are not the same thing. Despite assigning all baronies and bishoprics to courtiers I still. That means you are starting out with two titles, Petty King of Connachta, And Count of Connachta. ago Create a duchy and a kingdom. I just built a city in my capitol county, and it says "Holder is of wrong holding type". Each of these three types have an associated. I'm playing as Castille and have conquered a couple of Sunni provinces (states?) to the south. Early game they're cheap but get pricey quick. My vassal guy Ragnvald from Ormund decided. “Wrong type of Holding in demesne” I am really new to crusader king2 and just got it today I think I am playing as Romania or severin/timas I was…What penalties, if any, are there for a wrong holding type? E. If I select a vassal. . Being a republic unlocks the convert to city decision for you, which creates a holding of each type in the chosen province (if a temple already exists it will not be created). Some time ago - I'm not even sure it was my current ruler - I married somebody off into Bedford. So my count, which rules of two counties died. . makes sense. . Crusader Kings 2 is almost 5 years old, but the developers at Paradox are still producing new content for it in the form of patches and DLC. To lift the excommunication I gifted the Pope a county (Connact) to raise his opinion of me. There are five types of settlements, each with a different set of buildings. Why is it bad to govern cities directly? I am guessing it is bad since I got the message warning me. All but 2 are coastal. It. A. . Holdings with the wrong government penalty almost always give less resources then if it was filtered throught a vassal with the correct government. I have looked at the titles for that county (Perfeddwlad - Wales) and I have nothing for the Major of Dendigh which the title was originally. I just built a city in my capitol county, and it says "Holder is of wrong holding type". Do I have to give mayorship of this town to one of my vassals? If I do that or don't what are the economic consequenses? I saved for a long time to build this town so I could bring in some more cash. Do I have to give mayorship of this town to one of my vassals? If I do that or don't what are the economic consequenses? I saved for a long time to build this town so I could bring in some more cash. Some time ago - I'm not even sure it was my current ruler - I married somebody off into Bedford. Thread starter Jaol; Start date Feb 26,. What is the actual penalty for holding these?I just built a city in my capitol county, and it says "Holder is of wrong holding type". The capital of a province could change from a castle to a city in the same province if you have both in your demesne. Still super new to this game and I'm in need of some help. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. Ck2 Holder Is Of Wrong Holding Type. I revoked it for myself and became a count worchester as I believe I am supposed to be. Years later, my current king inherits the county and now I have the "Wrong type of Holding in Demesne" message. The formula for each vassal is: Liege Taxes = Vassal Income x Tax Percentage x Penalty Modifiers. Some time ago - I'm not even sure it was my current ruler - I married somebody off into Bedford. Left-click on the "Explore Character Opinions" button. 700+. So all I can build are castles (and still own them)?? So I have to give yet another holding away? Build a city of your own and give it away. . makes sense. Wrong Type of Holding When I click on my capital, it no longer has the options to build anything and when i look at the intrigue panel again, it still says adopt feudalism but now I can't do it anymore because it says I need a. New posts All threads Latest threads New posts Trending threads. Thanks in advance. Forums. . Jump to latest Follow Reply. To lift the excommunication I gifted the Pope a county (Connact) to raise his opinion of me. I'm currently the Petty King of Meath. Tax Percentage is set by liege law. Level 5, cost 400, income 3. are they baronage. Bedford has a castle and I'm still tribal. . makes sense. On macOS (US), ⌥Option + 6 enters. 0) If you are using the 'Way of Life' DLC you must either have Business Focus, or instead be of Vaishya caste. I'm playing a small count in Germany (Altmark), and after acquiring Mecklenburg from the pagans I am faced with various problems. Years later, my current king inherits the county and now I have the "Wrong type of Holding in Demesne" message. I'm currently the Petty King of Meath. To lift the excommunication I gifted the Pope a county (Connact) to raise his opinion of me. A holding will receive pretty significant tax and levy penalties with the wrong type of ruler. Note that this means the type of one or more of your provinces could change when you become a republic. 1. If a character owns an additional holding that is of a different type from this first holding, he or she will get the wrong holding type penalty on that holding. I don't understand this. Fast forward a generation and the. 23 total. makes sense. Some time ago - I'm not even sure it was my current ruler - I married somebody off into Bedford. Sounds like you're tribal and the holding is feudal. So all I can build are castles (and still own them)?? So I have to give yet another holding away? Build a city of your own and give it away. Do I have to give mayorship of this town to one of my vassals? If I do that or don't what are the economic consequenses? I saved for a long time to build this town so I could bring in some more cash. Empty holding slots in demesne provinces serve as grazing grounds for the nomadic population and armies. The more the better. Still super new to this game and I'm in need of some help. . Bedford has a castle and I'm still tribal. Which counties do you keep for yourself and never give out to vassals in your playthroughs? I usually keep the traditional capital and all duchies/counties. Tribalism is an early form of government, and one of three playable non-feudal government types in CK2 (the other two being merchant republics and nomadism . I'm currently the Petty King of Meath. 8. For example, my capital has 6 slots, all of them belong to different vassals and I don't even seem to have a claim on them (even though I'm the heir, if the current title holder dies and I get it, it will just say "wrong type of holding"). Yxklyx Feb 17, 2016 @ 9:19am. Still super new to this game and I'm in need of some help. All but 2 are coastal. As the map receives further updates, the number of holdings may increase. But I can't give it away. As Poland, I conquered the Pommeranian tribes to the north. Generally speaking, castles are best. Thank you. Settlements [edit | edit source]. Last edited by Nea's Nose ; Mar 17, 2021 @ 8:18pm. Ck2 Wrong Type Of Holding In Demesne. ? Long story short, I was ruling as the king of Ireland but my character had terrible traits and was hated by everyone and was eventually excommunicated, making everyone hate me more. . ? Long story short, I was ruling as the king of Ireland but my character had terrible traits and was hated by everyone and was eventually excommunicated, making everyone hate me more. I'd love any advice or explanation you have. Some time ago - I'm not even sure it was my current ruler - I married somebody off into Bedford. I'm currently the Petty King of Meath. I have de jure claims on Worchester, it was ruled by a prince-bishop since the capital of the county is temple. Bedford has a castle and I'm still tribal. Thank you. Slows down sieges and resists raiding. ? Long story short, I was ruling as the king of Ireland but my character had terrible traits and was hated by everyone and was eventually excommunicated, making everyone hate me more. I always build castles (when it lets me choose). So should I just spread out my demesne across the entire realm, with few castles here and there, instead of controlling everything. What exactly does this mean?If there's no castle, then you'd need to build one then give the barony away, if the castle holder is your vassal, you can try to revoke the castle title, make it the primary holding, then give the barony away. Also, as you are just starting out odds are you are a Petty King, which is the same as a Duke, rather then an actual King. . . Thank you. 700+. Everything I fight for goes to someone else so people have said to build your own in your own counties. Am I supposed to spend a bunch of money to upgrade the tribe into a castle? Do I have to build a castle from.